Bethany Sports Cards Plus

Bethany Beach’s trusted store for sports cards, Pokemon, collectibles, and more!

Upgrade Your Collection

Get your cards graded

Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)

Starting at $30/card

Add instant credibility and protection. PSA’s trusted grading standards help maximize your card’s value, make it easier to sell or trade, and give collectors confidence in its authenticity and condition. A PSA-graded card is recognized worldwide and often commands a premium on the market.

Sportscard Guaranty Corporation (SGC)

Starting at $30/card

Grading your card with SGC offers trusted accuracy, fast turnaround times, and a sharp, professional look. SGC’s reputation for strict grading and their signature black tuxedo slab make your card stand out, helping boost both its value and appeal to serious collectors.

From Rookies to Legends, We Have it all

Wax Boxes

mantle-graded-card

Graded Cards

Pokemon

Jerseys

Raw Cards

Memorabilia

Why The Plus?

Industry Connections

Along our journey we have made great connections with auction houses, wholesale distributors, grading companies, and direct manufacturers. We provide advice to our customers as a way to pay forward what we have learned to give back to our Hobby Community

Personal guidance and support

We are here to help in multiple capacities. Grading questions? Value questions? General questions? We are here to provide educated answers.

Grading Submissions

We specialize in an enhanced Grading Submissions program to SGC & PSA. Along with sending your cards in, we offer a review of your card to see if it has a chance to get the grade you desire. We use a Tomlov microscope to thoroughly review all aspects of the card.

Family environment

Along with our shops #1 priority, bringing value to our customers: we provide a family atmosphere for all ages. To us, family is everything and we love to see smiles!